- Thread starter
- #101
Dad, it has nothing to do with whats on the film. My position is only an opinion, just like the guy analyzing the film and writing the article. Its not right and its not wrong. Its just an opinion. DGF's position is that he is getting better as evidenced by this article. Well, just because has executed a play correctly on occasion does not, in my mind, mean that he is getting better. He has always occasionally executed plays. Its not like he failed 100% of time. In fact, he probably succeeds more than he fails. But I don't see any consistency to led me to the OPINION that he is improving. He seems to make the same mistakes with the same frequency as he did early last year.
As for my position, I'm curious if you even know what it is. I honestly feel I am one of the most middle of the road posters when it comes to RG3. I am disappointed, but not ready to give up on him. But I'm also of the opinion that if he isn't going to work out, for what ever reason, have a back up plan. Hell, Shanahan did when he drafted KC. This is year 3 for RG3. If after 3 years as an NFL QB, he still can't read defenses or get rid of the ball in a timely fashion, then I have serious concerns that he ever will. So developing a Plan B makes perfect sense to me. That is not to say cut him after this year. But have options as you go into next year and open up the job for competition. As Shark said above, why the concern over bringing in competition? Is he that fragile that he would implode? Why is that such a far fetched concept as DGF makes it out to be? If he rises to the challenge, he should beat out any competition we bring in here.
i dont think the film is opinion at all it shows exactly what he did
and the bad film will show what he did wrong and that will be as much fact as the good
hey i have no issue if they bring in someone to compete for the job
my issue is you say he cant read defenses , in this game he did
getting rid of the ball in a timely fashion , that will come in time but it is also well known that running qbs take time getting rid of the ball
in time he will get better but we need to have patience while this is worked out
he has 7 games to show it then all bets are off