Tony Romo wins a championship

[TheRobotDevil]

I'll get you the rest of Elis when I'm done Romo was terrible in the play offs tho.....

 

[TheRobotDevil]

I very much look forward to that.

Heres Elis next time you really may want to base your argument on actual numbers. Have fun comparing Eli is the better QB and its not close. As much as I don't like the Giants the guy knows how to win.

2006 NFC WC Giants 20 Philly 23

16/27 164 yards passing 2 TD 1 INT 0 fumbles

Eli comes up just short as philly hits a last second FG

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2007 NFC Divisional Rd Giants 21 Cowboys 17

12/18 163 yards passing 2 TD 0 INT 0 Fumbles

Manning leads the Giants past Romo and advance

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2007 NFC Championship Giants 23 packers 20

21/40 251 yards passing 0 TD 0 INT 0 Fumbles

Eli Drives the giants down the field for the TD that brings the game to OT. Then drives them to the OT winning FG

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2007 Super Bowl

18/34 255 yards passing 2 TD 1 INT 0 fumbles

I think you know what happened. Eli leads the Giants down the field with time running down. Defeating the Patriots and ending their undefeated season.

Manning wins Super Bowl MVP

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2008 NFC Divisional Rd Eagles 23 Giants 11

15/29 169 yards passing 0 TD 2 INT 0 Fumbles

If you want me to Cherry pick. This is the same eagles team that beat Romo and the Cowboys 44 - 06.Knocking Dallas out of a play off berth. Romo had an INT and 2 Fumbles that game

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2011 NFC WC Giants 24 falcons 2

23/32 277 yards passing 3 TD 0 INT 0 Fumbles

Eli was in complete control of this game

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2011 Divisional Rd Giants 37 Packers 20

21/33 30 yards passing 3 TD 1 INT 0 Fumbles

Eli does what Romo couldn’t and tops Rodgers

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2011 NFC Championship Giants 20 49ers 17

32/58 316 yards passing 2 Tds 0 INts 1 Fumble

Eli pulls off another clutch play with 31 yard game winning TD pass to Tynes in OT

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Super Bowl Giants 24 Patriots 20

20/39 250 yards passin 2 TD passes 1 INT 0 fumboes

You know how it goes Eli upsets the pats again. With another clutch last minute TD drive

And wins another Super Bowl MVP…

 

[TheRobotDevil]

2016 NFC WC Packers 38 Giants 13

23/44 299 yards passing 1 TD 1 INT 1 fumble

Elis worst game of the batch. But as a whole his numbers and success Trump Romo by quite a bit

 

[Manster7588]

2009 NFC Divisional Rd Vikings 34 Dallas 3

23/35 198 yards passing 0 TDs 1 Interception 3 fumbles

The old Romo returns……Complete disaster

That disaster was 100% on the OL.

Instead of just numbers open your eyes and watch them play. Romo is much better than Eli.

 

[Manster7588]

2014 NFC Divisional Rd Packers 26Dallas 21

15/19 191 yards passing 2 TD 0 INT 2 Fumbles

Failed to come through at the end with the game on the line following a GB TD

Again I'm guessing you didn't watch the game.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

Again I'm guessing you didn't watch the game.

I actually watched all the games and the beauty of using box scores. Not only do you get the stats but the summaries and recaps. Unlike megladon I actually put the work in....... Not hard I work in details

And no I'm not responsible for the NFL catch rule. ....Dallas benefitted from the Megatron play etc....

 

[TheRobotDevil]

That disaster was 100% on the OL.

Instead of just numbers open your eyes and watch them play. Romo is much better than Eli.

And you could make the same excuses for eli as far as several positions on the teams he played for. But Eli found a way to win in the play offs.This is also where stats like passer rating are useless....

 

[Manster7588]

I actually watched all the games and the beauty of using box scores. Not only do you get the stats but the summaries and recaps. Unlike megladon I actually put the work in....... Not hard I work in details

And no I'm not responsible for the NFL catch rule. ....Dallas benefitted from the Megatron play etc....

I'm not talking about the catch rule.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

I'm not talking about the catch rule.

In the end it really doesn't matter. I get we can all be homers I can be a major SC homer but i'll admit it when thats the case. True Ive never liked the giants. I live in NY and their fans can be very annoying at times. There will always be variables one of many reason using passer rating is asinine. But if we are being objective and breaking everything down. By both the numbers , results and games. As much as some of us may not like it when you break it down. and it comes down to it. Between Manning and Romo Manning is the better QB on multiple levels.

 

[Manster7588]

In the end it really doesn't matter. I get we can all be homers I can be a major SC homer but i'll admit it when thats the case. True Ive never liked the giants. I live in NY and their fans can be very annoying at times. There will always be variables one of many reason using passer rating is asinine. But if we are being objective and breaking everything down. By both the numbers , results and games. As much as some of us may not like it when you break it down. and it comes down to it. Between Manning and Romo Manning is the better QB on multiple levels.

That's your opinion, too bad it's wrong. If you stopped just looking at numbers and watch them play the game you'd see it.
I've been called a Romo Lover and a Romo Hater. Thing is while some blame does lay on Romo's shoulders but fact is too many people lay too much blame on his shoulders.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

That's your opinion, too bad it's wrong. If you stopped just looking at numbers and watch them play the game you'd see it.
I've been called a Romo Lover and a Romo Hater. Thing is while some blame does lay on Romo's shoulders but fact is too many people lay too much blame on his shoulders.

Opinion would be I think Carson Palmer is under rated especially given what he accomplished following his injury. What I gave you is an assessment based on the combination of statistics, performance, history, ability to handle big game pressure.Its not an opinion its an educated assessment based on direct comparisons of both players involved without bias.

 

[Manster7588]

Opinion would be I think Carson Palmer is under rated especially given what he accomplished following his injury. What I gave you is an assessment based on the combination of statistics, performance, history, ability to handle big game pressure.Its not an opinion its an educated assessment based on direct comparisons of both players involved without bias.

An assessment based solely on stats is nothing more than an opinion.