Best QB of All Time Game 8

[Nosferatu]

Joe Montana vs Otto Graham

Vote and Discuss...

 

[Wazmankg]

Graham was even before my time. Gotta go with Joe. Graham won several championships and put up some great numbers but most of his success was in the AAFC which only had about 3 good teams.

 

[mrwallace2ku]

Never saw Otto play...Father of the modern pass some say...Well so was Josef Montana, a Golden Domer who exceeded his college playing days and rewrote the NFL by careers end.

He goes all time #1 in my book. Ran, scrambled, threw darts and had a nice soft touch when he needed one...TERRIFIC QB

 

[tzorn10]

Joe

 

[Clayton]

These are arguably the top 2

 

[Nosferatu]

These are arguably the top 2

Just did the old draw names out of a hat thing, actually I used a bowl but I figured people would find a reason to bitch no matter how I did it so...

 

[Psych-Ward]

This is a tough call, If Joe played back in the day when Otto did he would of gotten killed for sure....
But Otto would have never cut it in the day of Joe, so this is really a tough sale.

I had to say Joe for the simple fact we all were in awe over those 4 super bowls!!!

 

[Wazmankg]

This is a tough call, If Joe played back in the day when Otto did he would of gotten killed for sure....
But Otto would have never cut it in the day of Joe, so this is really a tough sale.

I had to say Joe for the simple fact we all were in awe over those 4 super bowls!!!

Don't be so sure about that. They were the same size and Graham was also a 1st team all-American in hoops. He went to college on a hoops scholarship.

 

[Clayton]

Just did the old draw names out of a hat thing, actually I used a bowl but I figured people would find a reason to bitch no matter how I did it so...

Eh, bitchin is half the fun with these. There is no wrong answer.

Besides, I can already tell you that Steve Young wont lose until he runs into Montana.

 

[Psych-Ward]

Don't be so sure about that. They were the same size and Graham was also a 1st team all-American in hoops. He went to college on a hoops scholarship.

The game today is so fast paced as in comparison to how it used to be back in the day!!! I mean back then the few guys like Butkus, Deacon Jones, and Joe Greene were like freaks of nature back .... By todays standards they would be average players!!!!

Not taking anything away from Otto, I just think Montana had the better supporting cast to get the job done.

 

[Psych-Ward]

 

[Sportsguy9695]

never saw Otto play so MONTANA got my vote

 

[RoboticDreams]

Who the hell voted for Graham? Must be Seahawk fans.