Rookies of the year

[eaglesnut]

Nacua was incredible all year. He should win it. Stroud was good and is a franchise QB, but he didn't have a year like Puka.

 

[Mebert]

leading the league in interception percentage as a rookie on a team that was 3 and 13 the year prior.

Nacua was on a team that won a super bowl 2 years ago.

Nacua had a great year but this isn't even close in terms of impact

Rams 2 years ago have nothing to do with the current team. They cratered, traded vets, and rebuilt in those 2 years. Nakua was a huge part if the quick turnaround.

Still should be Stroud.

 

[eaglesnut]

105-1486-6

Those are prime numbers, not rookie numbers.

Yards - 4th
Receptions - 8th

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Nacua was incredible all year. He should win it. Stroud was good and is a franchise QB, but he didn't have a year like Puka.

except if not for a concussion Stroud would have been considered for the actual MVP! (which would have solved this dilemma)

Stroud wins it.

 

[eaglesnut]

except if not for a concussion Stroud would have been considered for the actual MVP! (which would have solved this dilemma)

Stroud wins it.

With only 23 TDs he really didn't do enough. He should have double that many when he's in his prime.