Rookies of the year

[Battlelyon]

 

[Battlelyon]

I'm being bias but my two Rams but not really. Imagine something thst has never been done a non qb fifth rounder winning it Of course they are giving it to Stroud and probsbly Carter.

 

[Niner Outlaw]

Stroud, Nacua and LaPorta are all worthy of the award imo. But we all know Stroud will probably win it. Fine.

DROY...my vote, under extreme protest, goes to Turner or Witherspoon. I mean, really, what kind of person with any dignity can vote for the Rams and Squawks without at least some protest?

 

[Battlelyon]

Stroud, Nacua and LaPorta are all worthy of the award imo. But we all know Stroud will probably win it. Fine.

DROY...my vote, under extreme protest, goes to Turner or Witherspoon. I mean, really, who can vote for the Rams and Squawks without at least some protest?

 

[redskinsfan1963]

stroud and carter

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

I think Nacua should win it, tbh. Obviously, Stroud plays the marquis position and had an absolutely outstanding first season. But Nacua broke records and would be my choice. What should happen and what will are often totally different.
As for defense, won't be surprised if they give it to Carter because he's on the east coast and had a solid rookie season but obviously, my homer bias wants Witherspoon to get it and I honestly think he deserves it over Carter although neither one had any great impact down the stretch. Turner probably deserves some consideration but hard to say what happens.

 

[ANGELAKERAMS]

Stroud will win because he is a QB, but if ever there was a year to have Co-ROY, it’s this year. Because what Puka did as a 5th round pick is unprecedented.

If they can have Co-MVP’s, why not Co-ROY? They both deserve it.

 

[Mebert]

Branch not winning is absolutely fair, not being a finalist is some bullshit. He was awesome this year.

 

[Money]

Stroud did something as a rookie that only Brady and Montana have done (in the prime of their careers) in the last 50 years. He led the league in both passing yards per game and TD/INT ratio. That's ridiculous if you think about it.

Puka had a fantastic year, but Stroud should clearly be the OROY.

 

[fightinfunbags]

Stroud and Carter

 

[belcherboy]

Nacua breaks a 60+ year old rookie receiving record and still probably doesn't win ROY. Crazy! I wish they would just go ahead and create awards for QB's exclusively, and awards for all the other players separately. CMac (MVP) and Nacua (ROY) would be my two choices. It's sad that most contracts hve bonuses for these awards, but it's almost surely going to go to a QB every year, so these guys won't get that bonus.

 

[broncosmitty]

Stroud should be unanimous.

 

[Red_Chaos]

Its easier to make an impact as a Rookie qb, If Puka doesn't get it, I rather give it to LaPorta. Defensive I dont think Carter or Turner interest me enough. Both are working with decent supporting casts on the Dline.

 

[PDay8810]

Stroud should be unanimous.

i agree

no brainer

 

[PDay8810]

Its easier to make an impact as a Rookie qb, If Puka doesn't get it, I rather give it to LaPorta. Defensive I dont think Carter or Turner interest me enough. Both are working with decent supporting casts on the Dline.

disagree. No position in team sports has the demands of NFL QB. Puka had a great year.

 

[Battlelyon]

Carter

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Stroud will win because QB.

Carter will win because Philly made the playoffs, it's Philly (East Coast team) and while Witherspoon was by far the best CB in the league, somehow Porter gets on there because team and name. Whatever.

Carter/Stroud. Derp and derp.

 

[Battlelyon]

Carter will win because Philly made the playoffs, it's Philly (East Coast team) and while Witherspoon was by far the best CB in the league, somehow Porter gets on there because team and name. Whatever.

Carter/Stroud. Derp and derp.

 

[fightinfunbags]

View attachment 352484

Already a top ten DT in the league. Actually graded out as the 6th best DT in the NFL and that’s with him hitting the rookie wall in the last 6-7 contests. And let’s be honest… not a great pool here after Carter.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

View attachment 352502

OHHHH... my dogs are barkin' today....

lmao love that movie.