this is a fair comment
Yeah, I'm not advocating trading everything just to get a QB. I do hope they are aggressive, as long as it makes sense.
and that everyone in the FO and RR are on the SAME page
For once.
nope i have maintained that wins arent a qb stat but the people who make cases for DW' somehow forget that . stafford is a borderline HOF qb and his wins and losses arent on him . no one says stafford chokes and if you are asking for 3 number ones , some number 2's and some core players then you need to know that DW isnt much different then those others mentioned
I'm not sure about them, but I always see you bring up the Vikings defense when it comes to Kirk, yet continously lead with W/L when it comes to Watson.
Why would you give up assets for Carr? His playoff wins? None. His playoff appearances? None until now and quite frankly, if it were not for a GAWD AWFUL Chargers defense he would still have no playoff appearances. While he a viable option as you state, the assets to be given up are not worth the return. Will Carr really be made available or will Mariota be made available?
his arm talent
How many assets would you give, curious?
I lead with that Watson wins stuff because of the debate against KC is wins and stat padding . Either you have a standard ( wins mean everything) or you don’t and if it’s used against KC then hell by their own standards I should be able to bring up their guys record .
Grap didn’t take the 49ers anywhere . The team helped him along . Carr hasn’t played on as good a teams as Grap .
FACT: JG has taken his team to the playoffs more than Carr. The Raiders are not giving up Carr, they have viable replacement.
The 49ers have a better team and more stability at HC
The answer I expected.
The Raiders changed coaches mid season and made the PO. Never been done since what, 1912, lol. What has Kyle Shannahan ever won? I will admit, he is a good play caller, I'll give you that.
He has been to a couple of super bowls as a HC and OC
He has a losing record as HC but did win the NFC once. I believe his collapse on offense in half #2 as the OC cost ATL a super bowl. That's what Kyle has done. I would never want him back as our HC because his dad is a dolt and they left a stain on the legacy of REDSKINS.
Im not hating on Cali, but if im raiders brass, the last thing I'm doing is trading Carr, he's cheap on the cap, had an amazing start to the season, and was a true leader despite tragedy and distraction. I can't believe im gonna say this, but Mayock sucks at his job, at least in the draft. The raiders should be waaaay better than they are. Trading carr for payne and a 1st would be illogical
