Which of these QBs is the best? (No cheating)

[Johnnydollaz89]

Tough call between B and C but figure the 600yrds and TD make up for the 3 more picks... but again, tough call.

Agreed. This was my dilemma as well

 

[Dude]

C.


...And by the "no cheating" qualifier, does that mean Tom Brady was left off the list?

Damn, that was pretty clever.

 

[packerzrule]

Not Russell Wilson

 

[The Oldtimer]

I'm going with C

I'm going with C too. I know who C is and I didn't look.

 

[Dude]

Refuse to vote in a poll that doesn't contain potato salad or bacon sandwich on the list. You pros should know that by now.

 

[GNG]

C

 

[HaroldSeattle]

C

OK that surprises me.

 

[Dude]

C

Bah, typical one liner, word, letter, from G&G.

 

[Dude]

Have a good night everyone, got to get some sleep to get there in time for 7:30 am tee time. Yeah, living in the tropics has its advantages.

 

[DunceKaep]

Cam Newton is the obvious MVP this season.
He has accomplished everything, so what that he didn't pass for 4000+ yards.

FACT is he played huge, led his team to 15 RS victories, the win @Sea on my birthday sucked, but it was still a great day, had great seats.

Best Rushing QB in the game, RW is smarter with his rushes, he rarely gets hit, but Cam is still the better rusher.

Comp %, How many TD passes did Ginn drop. I know Ginn actually caught many, but, FACT, Ginn and other Panther receivers had a plethora of drops, that's a bunch folks.

Give Cam his credit. Low passing yards can still be the MVP. 100% Cam is the NFL, 2015-6 MVP.

 

[GNG]

OK that surprises me.

It shouldn't.

 

[GNG]

Bah, typical one liner, word, letter, from G&G.

The OP only asked to pick a QB and not make a dissertation.

 

[RobToxin]

I want to say something here for the OP and some of the other Seahawk fans.

Not all but some.

Quit feeling this need to validate Russell Wilson.

It's not necessary.

Russell Wilson has been the Seahawks starting quarterback for four seasons. In those four seasons, Seattle has made the playoffs four times, the Super Bowl two times and won it all once.

Do you know how many teams would give anything to have a quarterback lead a team to that kind of four year run?

You don't need a multiple choice guess the quarterback stat comparison to validate Russell Wilson.

Quite honestly it makes you look insecure when you feel the need to get some message board wannabes to say "Oh okay, I guess since you put it that way, Russell Wilson is the bestestesteststestt over Cam Newton."

That is a colossal waste of time.

If that were my quarterback doing what Russell Wilson is doing, I would not give a flippity-fuck what any message board warrior said about him or whether they thought Cam was better.

Would you rather have any other quarterback under center for the Seahawks than Russell Wilson?

No?

Then that's all that matters.

 

[SteelersPride]

ok screw any thread that doesnt disclose who the choices are after 4 fricken days

 

[bksballer89]

ok screw any thread that doesnt disclose who the choices are after 4 fricken days

I thought he disclosed it already?

A was Brees
B was Brady
C was Wilson
D was Cam
E was Big Ben

Basically the OP used this thread to try and validate for his QB Wilson for some reason and to make Cam look like shit

 

[bksballer89]

Cam Newton is the obvious MVP this season.
He has accomplished everything, so what that he didn't pass for 4000+ yards.

FACT is he played huge, led his team to 15 RS victories, the win @Sea on my birthday sucked, but it was still a great day, had great seats.

Best Rushing QB in the game, RW is smarter with his rushes, he rarely gets hit, but Cam is still the better rusher.

Comp %, How many TD passes did Ginn drop. I know Ginn actually caught many, but, FACT, Ginn and other Panther receivers had a plethora of drops, that's a bunch folks.

Give Cam his credit. Low passing yards can still be the MVP. 100% Cam is the NFL, 2015-6 MVP.

Exactly. This thread was a really lame attempt to make Cam look bad. The OP is a piece of shit

 

[Jakology]

Rigged poll is rigged.

 

[tducey]

QB c.

 

[bksballer89]

B was actually Carson Palmer @SteelersPride

 

[SteelersPride]

who were the others.....