Which of these QBs is the best? (No cheating)

[seahawksfan234]

Exactly why the poll is stupid. Eliminating the rushing factor is nonsense

If I put the rushing factor in, it would be obvious who is who, which doesn't make it blind anymore.

A: 24 attempts 14 yards 0.6 YPC 1 TD
B: 25 attempts 24 yards 1.0 YPC 1 TD
C: 103 attempts 553 yards 5.4 YPC 1 TD
D: 132 attempts 636 4.8 YPC 10 TDs
E: 15 attempts 29 yards 0 TDs

 

[bksballer89]

If I put the rushing factor in, it would be obvious who is who, which doesn't make it blind anymore.

A: 24 attempts 14 yards 0.6 YPC 1 TD
B: 25 attempts 24 yards 1.0 YPC 1 TD
C: 103 attempts 553 yards 5.4 YPC 1 TD
D: 132 attempts 636 4.8 YPC 10 TDs
E: 15 attempts 29 yards 0 TDs

Its already obvious who is who. The only one that surprised me was E

 

[SteelersPride]

ok im too lazy fill me in whose who

 

[SoCalWizFan]

QB A: 69.8% Comp Pct 4166 yards 7.67 YDS/A 29 TD 11 INT 101.6 QB Rating
QB B: 65.3% Comp Pct 3231 yards 7.23 YDS/A 14 TD 9 INT 88.7 QB Rating


How about comparing stats for these 2 QBs. So - which one of these guys was just named as a replacement QB for the Pro Bowl? What a joke.

 

[redseat]

QB A: 69.8% Comp Pct 4166 yards 7.67 YDS/A 29 TD 11 INT 101.6 QB Rating
QB B: 65.3% Comp Pct 3231 yards 7.23 YDS/A 14 TD 9 INT 88.7 QB Rating


How about comparing stats for these 2 QBs. So - which one of these guys was just named as a replacement QB for the Pro Bowl? What a joke.

It's the Pro Bowl, you gives two shiats about that? It's a complete joke

 

[seahawksfan234]

ok im too lazy fill me in whose who

A: Drew Brees 68.3% Comp Pct 4870 yards 7.77 YDS/A 32 TD 11 INT 101 QB Rating
B: Carson Palmer 63.7% Comp Pct 4671 yards 8.70 YDS/A 35 TD 11 INT 104 QB Rating
C: Russell Wilson 68.1% Comp Pct 4024 yards 8.33 YDS/A 34 TD 8 INT 110.1 QB Rating
D: Cam Newton 59.8% Comp Pct 3837 yards 7.75 YDS/A 35 TD 10 INT 99.4 QB Rating
E: Ben Roethlisberger 68.0% Comp PCt 3938 yards 8.40 YDS/A 21 TD 16 INT 94.5 QB Rating

 

[RobToxin]

Lemme guess:

Poll is designed by an OP looking to validate his favorite quarterback.

And all it really ends up doing is making said OP look insecure about his quarterback's worth.

 

[bksballer89]

Lemme guess:

Poll is designed by an OP looking to validate his favorite quarterback.

And all it really ends up doing is making said OP look insecure about his quarterback's worth.

Basically and to shit on Cam again.....as he did yesterday morning.

 

[bksballer89]

This was one of the stupidest polls in SportsHoopla history.

This like posting a poll who is the best running back and you intentionally leave out receiving numbers for those running backs because you want one person to look bad

 

[SoCalWizFan]

It's the Pro Bowl, you gives two shiats about that? It's a complete joke

True. I don't care about the game but I believe the recognizing the players is good (just don't play the actual game).

 

[MISKO]

E

Peyton is the GOAT

E is ben

Ben Roethlisberger: Situational Stats at NFL.com

 

[jarntt]

I pick Romo...

 

[sonnyblack65]

E

Peyton is the GOAT

E is ben

Ben Roethlisberger: Situational Stats at NFL.com

he meant to say F
9 tds/17int 67 QBR

 

[Money]

I'm assuming these stats were accumulated with the QB being the only variable??? Otherwise...the poll is meaningless of course.

 

[Money]

Which of these QBs likes lima beans?

QB A: 68.3% Comp Pct 4870 yards 7.77 YDS/A 32 TD 11 INT 101 QB Rating

QB B: 63.7% Comp Pct 4671 yards 8.70 YDS/A 35 TD 11 INT 104 QB Rating

QB C: 68.1% Comp Pct 4024 yards 8.33 YDS/A 34 TD 8 INT 110.1 QB Rating

QB D: 59.8% Comp Pct 3837 yards 7.75 YDS/A 35 TD 10 INT 99.4 QB Rating

QB E: 68.0% Comp PCt 3938 yards 8.40 YDS/A 21 TD 16 INT 94.5 QB Rating

 

[Carnzo]

I went with X.
<Remembers racer X from speed racer>

 

[redseat]

True. I don't care about the game but I believe the recognizing the players is good (just don't play the actual game).

very true. as a lot of players don't play. Heck not a single Patriots player will go.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Andrew Luck

 

[handicappers]

he meant to say F
9 tds/17int 67 QBR

THIS

I don't care what the stats are, big forehead guy wins.

 

[DetroitFan*]

I picked based on the given stats. I think most did. You are just falling back on the "picked because he is on their team" thing because you don't want to admit that this specific stat set does show Wilson as the top or close to the top of the given options. Admitably these stats do not tell the whole story though.

No matter how great his rushing stats are (and they are damn good), I still have an issue with a QB who is 28th in the league in completion percentage being touted as the MVP. That is just wrong.

Does your statement mean that you would pick Stafford if his stats were put up there?

No, because I am not going to sit here and make a poll trying to toot my own team's horn.