Trade advice

[jeffro151]

Receive:
Russell Wilson
Dwayne Bowe

Send away:
Lamar Miller
Julian Edelman

I think I am going to be coming out great in this deal. Thoughts?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

dont do it... Depending on who you have at QB it is a terrible trade for you... Even if you need a QB unless this is the deepest league possible i would rather start tannehill and not trade miller or edelman...

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Too hard to tell... Who are your current QB, RB, and WR's? Gives us the bench players as well.

 

[jeffro151]

QB: SCHAUB
RB: RICE, GORE, P. THOMAS, L. MILLER, BRYCE BROWN, SNELLING
WR: GREEN, WELKER, MOORE, EDELMAN, HANKERSON
TE: GONZALEZ

 

[Chef99]

I like the trade...even before I saw the rest of your team.

 

[TREFF]

It's an even deal, especially given the need at QB! Losing the RB depth might hurt, but you can afford to lose Edelman.

I'd like it more if you got a minor RB back instead of Bowe, but still, it helps more than it hurts.

 

[The Foot]

i don't like bowe at all. His QB cant throw the ball deep thus all the dink and dunks to avery. Also Russell Wilson has not had a great start and looks early on like he may be heading down the dreaded road called sophmore slump avenue. miller is ready to launch a big game tomorrow and i say this is the week he puts himself on the map and takes control of all the carries going forward. i think you will regret this trade edelman aint going no either because you know even if amendola comes back at some point you know he will just be pulling someithing else or twisting something well else.

 

[tlance]

You may need a QB, but the value here sucks. Hold out. I would honestly rather have Edelman than Bowe for the rest of the season. Alex Smith is not good enough to support him.

Lamar Miller is the best player in this trade hands down. Wilson is a low end QB starter. Edelman for Wilson straight up would be more reasonable.

 

[Chef99]

You may need a QB, but the value here sucks. Hold out. I would honestly rather have Edelman than Bowe for the rest of the season. Alex Smith is not good enough to support him.

Lamar Miller is the best player in this trade hands down. Wilson is a low end QB starter. Edelman for Wilson straight up would be more reasonable.

Wow, I didn't realize everyone on here had such a low opinion of Wilson...is a guy like, say, Kaepernick so much better? Besides the fact that he has more weapons, I mean.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

I'd say it's a fair deal, but if I were you I wouldn't do it. Bowe is a matchup-based starter IMO. But from the looks of it, you don't need Bowe. As stated by many other, it would "upgrade" your QB but not sure by how much.

 

[tlance]

Wow, I didn't realize everyone on here had such a low opinion of Wilson...is a guy like, say, Kaepernick so much better? Besides the fact that he has more weapons, I mean.

Wilson is a great real life QB, but Seattle is all about a power run game and an elite defense. Wilson is a game manager because of his role. I bet there will be 4 or 5 more games this season like last week's. You can't put up big fantasy numbers if your team doesn't throw the ball.

Kaepernick has more upside because his team leans on him a little more.

 

[jeffro151]

Look at Schaubs next 7-8 games, very brutal. I accepted the trade. I think KC will work with Bowe on some underneath routes to get him the ball. Dolphins coach still says Miller will split carries evenly.

 

[Sox33OSU]

You've really gotta hope they get Bowe involved. They're 3-0 so it's not like they're having an issue with his lack of production. Wilson had you a day today, but not all games will be vs. Jax. I would've liked to see what QBs were on the waiver wire.

 

[jeffro151]

I think I will come out to the good considering Wilson alone scored more today than Schaub, Miller and Edelman did combined.