Prior to 1960 MLB Draft SF2 : Nos vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

NOS

LINEUP
1. Billy Hamilton (L) - CF
2. Rogers Hornsby (R) - 2B
3. Shoeless Joe Jackson (L) - LF
4. Hack Wilson (R) - DH
5. Mickey Cochrane (L) - C
6. Frank Howard (R) - 1B
7. Jesse Burkett (L) - RF
8. Lou Boudreau (R) - SS
9. John McGraw (L) - 3B

BENCH
Luis Aparicio (R) - SS/PR
George Van Haltren (L) - CF/PR
Babe Herman (L) - OF/1B

ROTATION
1. Walter Johnson (R)
2. Grover Cleveland Alexander (R)
3. Rube Waddell (L)
4. Smoky Joe Wood (R)
5. Chief Bender (R)

BULLPEN
Al Worthington (R)
Billy Hoeft (L)
Hal Woodeshick (L)

VS

SHANE

LINEUP
1. Willie Keeler (L) - DH
2. Nap Lajoie (R) - 2B
3. Mickey Mantle (B) - CF
4. Johnny Mize (L) - 1B
5. Ralph Kiner (R) - LF
6. Harry Heilmann (R) - RF
7. Gabby Hartnett (R) - C
8. Stan Hack (L) - 3B
9. Luke Appling - (R) - SS

BENCH
Chuck Klein (L) - RF
Arlie Latham (R) - 3B/PR
Dom DiMaggio (R) - CF

ROTATION
1. Warren Spahn (L)
2. Hal Newhouser (L)
3. Kid Nichols (R)
4. Dazzy Vance (R)
5. Amos Rusie (R)

BULLPEN
Don Mossi (L)
Ellis Kinder (R)
Johnny Murphy (R)

 

[Nosferatu]

NOS - 5
SHANE - 1

VOTED - UK, Meebs, Nos, Shane, 500, WLK

 

[wlk3]

In protest I got shane....





Losing

 

[UK Cowboy]

Real hard contest to pick. Shane has a fantastic lineup, better than Nos, who has a very good offense. Nos has the better starting pitching. It's really strength against strength, and I think the difference comes down to Nos scoring a little more against Shane's pitching than the other way around. I went back and forth on this one

Nos

 

[Mebert]

These are the 2 best teams in this. I think nos has a very slim advantage......very very very slim.

Nos

 

[Nosferatu]

Shane has a great lineup no question about it and I respect everyones opinion who think his lineup is better but I absolutely love my lineup.

I think my rotation is better.

I lean me.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I got me by a hair. I think my lineup has enough mix of power and small ball to beat his team IMO

Great team Nos

 

[Shanemansj13]

Didnt wlk vote for me? Lol

 

[Pack 500]

Nos

 

[Nosferatu]

I did text WLK, I wanna be sure who he voted for before we move on.

 

[Nosferatu]

Ok WLK said he was messin with me.

 

[wlk3]

I voted for Nos... I think his pitching was good enough for his offense to pull it out... it was close though

 

[Shanemansj13]

I voted for Nos... I think his pitching was good enough for his offense to pull it out... it was close though

You SOB!!! You gave me hope