NFL Franchise Unit Mock Draft Semi's 2: Milk vs 500

[Shanemansj13]

MILK

OFFENSE
QB-Tom Brady
RB-Priest Holmes
FB- Jim Brown
RB- Jamaal Charles
WR- Charley Taylor
WR-Art Monk
WR- Gary Clark
WR- Otis Taylor
TE- Jordan Reed
TE- Tony Gonzalez
LT- Anthony Munoz
RT- Willie Anderson
RG- Larry Little
LG- Bob Keuchenberg
C- Dwight stephenson
C- Jim Langer

DEFENSE(HYBRID 4-3,3-4)
RDE- Bruce Smith
LDE- Richard Dent
RDT- Dan Hampton
LDT- Steve McMichael
DT/NT- Ted Washington
LLB- Jack Ham
MLB-Jack Lambert
RLB- Larry Grantham
ILB- James Farrior
OLB- Greg Lloyd
CB- Rod Woodson
CB- Mel Blount
CB- Eric Allen
CB- Troy vincent
FS- Brian Dawkins
SS- Troy Polamalu
SS- Donnie Shell

Special Teams
Josh Cribbs

VS

500

OFFENSE
QB- Joe Montana
RB- Walter Payton
FB- William Andrews
RB- Gale Sayers
WR- Don Hutson
WR- James Lofton
WR- Sterling Sharpe
WR- Rod Smith
TE- Shannon Sharpe
TE- Paul Coffman
LT- Bruce Armstorng
LG- John Hannah
C- Joe Morris
RG- Russ Grimm
RT- Joe Jacoby
OL- Logan Mankins

DEFENSE (4-3)
DE- Michael Strahan
DT- Bob Lilly
DT- Randy White
DE- Charles Haley
DE- Too Tall Jones
OLB- Ted Hendricks
MLB- Luke Kuechly
OLB- Thomas Davis
MLB- Jon Beason
OLB- Rod Martin
CB- Lem Barney
CB- Dick LeBeau
CB- Jimmy Johnson
CB- Kermit Alexander
FS- Ronnie Lott
SS- Tim McDonald
S- Dwight Hicks

SPECIAL TEAMS
KR- Tyrone Hughes

 

[Shanemansj13]

MILK - 2

500 - 4

VOTED: Bolts, Shane, 500, UK, Ritz, WLK

 

[Bolts]

500

 

[Bolts]

MILK -

500 -

VOTED:

 

[Shanemansj13]

500 has the better offense, Milk the better defense. I got Milk by a hair

 

[Pack 500]

500 has the better offense, Milk the better defense. I got Milk by a hair

The difference between the offenses is much greater than the defenses. I got me here

 

[Ritzarmy]

Dear God no wonder I lost in first round playing 500. First time I got to look at all the teams and seeing 500's I would have selected him over me and I got 500 beating well everyone. He has the #1 QB Montana of all time, #1-3 RB Payton of all time, a amazing backup RB in Sales, #1-3 WR of all time Hutson, #1-3 TE Sharpe of all time, #1-3 LG Hannah of all-time, then you look at that defense and I get a hand cramp from all the typing. Amazing team 500. Not saying Milks team is bad but my god how great 500's is.

 

[UK Cowboy]

I think Milks team is a little stronger overall

Milk

 

[wlk3]

Man I have to look at this again... I'll be back, that secondary of Milks made me do a double take...

 

[wlk3]

Damn it, I thought there were more games so I have to look at this some more...

 

[wlk3]

So I voted 500 then deleted I and here's why... at first view I felt 500 had the better offense Milk the better defense but the difference in the flip went to 500... I then looked again as I was about to click out and noticed Rod Woodson, Mel Blount, Brian Dawkins and Troy Polomalu looking at me saying seriously... so here's the thing, I think Milk has the ability to shut down the pass... however as a collective I don't think his LBs will hold up to stopping sweetness and Shannon Sharpe while the rest of the guys are doing their job... so 500 in a squeaker

 

[Ritzarmy]

I think Milks team is a little stronger overall

Milk

I disagree. I think Milks defense is slightly better but I feel 500's offense is much better. Its not a run away with either side and would be close but think 500's O would just out last Milks great D.

 

[Shanemansj13]

I actually think Milk has the perfect defense to limit 500. I do think Milk's offense is a little lacking though at the WR position. I think this would be a low scoring battle. Brown vs Sweetness

 

[Shanemansj13]

Congrats 500

 

[UK Cowboy]

I disagree. I think Milks defense is slightly better but I feel 500's offense is much better. Its not a run away with either side and would be close but think 500's O would just out last Milks great D.

That's your right, I just don't see it. Milks offense has Brady, Brown, Gonzalez and Munoz, guys I could make a STRONG argument are the greatest at their position ever, no question top two each. So a guy with possibly the greatest QB, RB, LT and TE ever gets beat on offense? Not likely

 

[Shanemansj13]

Dear God no wonder I lost in first round playing 500. First time I got to look at all the teams and seeing 500's I would have selected him over me and I got 500 beating well everyone. He has the #1 QB Montana of all time, #1-3 RB Payton of all time, a amazing backup RB in Sales, #1-3 WR of all time Hutson, #1-3 TE Sharpe of all time, #1-3 LG Hannah of all-time, then you look at that defense and I get a hand cramp from all the typing. Amazing team 500. Not saying Milks team is bad but my god how great 500's is.

It's not like Milk has scrubs. First off, look at his defense, secondary and LB's then he doesn't have a ton of playmakers on offense but he has some of the best and Brady isn't too bad. They both have playmakers at key positions 500 just has more depth on offense. So it is closer than you think, could go either way honestly.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I agree that my WRs are lacking... But that is the only place i am weak at...

I do understand, WRs are key, but I would take MY OL, LBs, and secondary all over his.... I think our DLs are pretty much a tie, maybe small edge to 500... QB his is better, but we both are ELITE... and despite me having Weak WRs, I have the best TE in football and I have 2 HOF WR...

Clearly i have me... But Knew it would be an uphill battle for my team with my WRs... But a little disappointed that it is factored in SOOO much...

 

[femurov]

500