DK or TK?

[TKOSpikes]

12 team keeper, PPR
Keep 6 (can keep forever, no round bargains just first six picks of draft)
QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, RWT Flex, K, DST

My roster
QB - Watson, Cam
RB - Conner, Bell, Gaskin, Boone, Breida, Perine, Darrell Williams, Penny (IR)
WR - Evans, Golladay, Metcalf, Hardman, Higgins, Harry
TE - Gronk, Goedert (IR) .... just turfed Hurst.


Would you trade DK Metcalf for Travis Kelce?

Currently 2-3

 

[MilkSpiller22]

12 team keeper, PPR
Keep 6 (can keep forever, no round bargains just first six picks of draft)
QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, RWT Flex, K, DST

My roster
QB - Watson, Cam
RB - Conner, Bell, Gaskin, Boone, Breida, Perine, Darrell Williams, Penny (IR)
WR - Evans, Golladay, Metcalf, Hardman, Higgins, Harry
TE - Gronk, Goedert (IR) .... just turfed Hurst.


Would you trade DK Metcalf for Travis Kelce?

Currently 2-3

Boy that’s tough. You don’t have a TE and you are starting a wr at flex every week.

and this is a keeper??

I guess the keeper part is enough to prefer Metcalf.

but I may change my mind every 10 minutes if this was me.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Boy that’s tough. You don’t have a TE and you are starting a wr at flex every week.

and this is a keeper??

I guess the keeper part is enough to prefer Metcalf.

but I may change my mind every 10 minutes if this was me.

YeahI agree with this...looking at your roster, DK is line to be your keeper. Not sure I would ever keep a TE that is aging. You’re in a tough spot but that’s the only reasoning on not making this trade

 

[TKOSpikes]

I was thinking of countering with Evans, but don't want to reject.

This is his counter to my Watson-Higgins for Kelce-Carr offer. (He has Burrow and Carr)

 

[TKOSpikes]

I still think I might...

Evans and Golladay are still good keeps.
Conner and Bell... well, with the RB on waivers, I have to keep them.
Hardman is my love child.
Higgins looks like a great up and comer.

I like to win. Win now.
Does Goedert come back in week 7? And does he produce? I'm not so sure on either....

Metcalf's schedule... scare anyone?
Zona (PP step up?)
SF (struggling, Sherman coming back?)
Buffalo (struggling with injuries)
Rams (#1 pass D)
Zona (again)
Philly
Giants
Jets
Washington (ranked high in pass D... is that because teams run all over them?)
Rams (#1 pass D in championship week)

Could be some ups and downs there.
Long term, he is an absolute stud.

 

[wildturkey]

I'd do it. You've got other good WRs that you can keep to help ease the loss. You don't really have a TE. Who knows with Goedert. He was getting targets early but it still seemed like it was one week Ertz was the one getting fantasty points and then Goedert next week. Kelce will be consistent. And you should get at least another 2 good years out of him, especially with a healthy Mahomes. DK has talent and is good but you gotta give up good if you're getting Kelce.

 

[TKOSpikes]

I'd do it. You've got other good WRs that you can keep to help ease the loss. You don't really have a TE. Who knows with Goedert. He was getting targets early but it still seemed like it was one week Ertz was the one getting fantasty points and then Goedert next week. Kelce will be consistent. And you should get at least another 2 good years out of him, especially with a healthy Mahomes. DK has talent and is good but you gotta give up good if you're getting Kelce.

yup... I ended up accepting.