Division Mount Rushmore

[Battlelyon]

For the NFC West

Joe Montana
Jerry Rice
Aaron Donald
JJ Watt

Individual teams

Rams
Marshall Faulk
Aaron Donald
Deacon Jones
Eric Dickerson

Seahawks
Steve Largent
Bobby Wagner
Cortez Kennedy
Walter Jones

49ers
Joe Montana
Jerry Rice
Ronnie Lott
Trent Williams?

Cards
Larry Fitzgerald
JJ Watt
Roger Wehrli
Aeneas Williams

 

[broncosmitty]

JJ Watt played 23 games for an NFC West team.

 

[shopson67]

Does Faulk make the list ahead of Warner? You could also go older school with one of those four (but it's tough to single one out from Van Brocklin, Gabriel, Hirsch, etc).

 

[molsaniceman]

JJ Watt played 23 games for an NFC West team.

yea its merlin olsen or larry fitz

 

[Battlelyon]

JJ Watt played 23 games for an NFC West team.

Lol, i don't know why i was thinking he played longer there

 

[Battlelyon]

Does Faulk make the list ahead of Warner? You could also go older school with one of those four (but it's tough to single one out from Van Brocklin, Gabriel, Hirsch, etc).

Of course, Faulk was the best player in football in his prime. Even Wsrner will tell you the offense ran through Faulk.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Steve Young

 

[Clayton]

Patrick Mahomes
John Elway
Travis Kelce
Taylor Swift

 

[PDay8810]

Does Faulk make the list ahead of Warner? You could also go older school with one of those four (but it's tough to single one out from Van Brocklin, Gabriel, Hirsch, etc).

Roman Gabriel ?

LOL

 

[Clayton]

I'd feel bad doing a Chiefs Mt Rushmore because I feel it would be disrespectful to the older players. Chiefs had some darn good teams before I was alive but Tony G, Kelce, Derrick Thomas, and Mahomes would be hard to beat as a top 4 at this point.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I'd feel bad doing a Chiefs Mt Rushmore because I feel it would be disrespectful to the older players. Chiefs had some darn good teams before I was alive but Tony G, Kelce, Derrick Thomas, and Mahomes would be hard to beat as a top 4 at this point.

meh... when you are in the best dynasty a franchise has ever had, of course their mount rushmore will be at least one player from that time...

id not feel bad, that is the teams clear best choices...

 

[Pure Steel]

Roman Gabriel ?

LOL

Great actor as well......

 

[Shanemansj13]

I'd feel bad doing a Chiefs Mt Rushmore because I feel it would be disrespectful to the older players. Chiefs had some darn good teams before I was alive but Tony G, Kelce, Derrick Thomas, and Mahomes would be hard to beat as a top 4 at this point.

I think this is a special case. Mahomes and Kelce are two of the best ever, Mahomes already. That top 4 looks accurate.

I mean the Patriots would have more recent guys as well: Brady, Gronk, but also old school guys like Hannah, Law, Seymour, Tippett.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Steve Young

Trent Williams over Steve Young is blasphemy especially since he's only played four seasons in San Fran

 

[shopson67]

Roman Gabriel ?

LOL

He was an MVP, comeback player of the year, 4x pro bowl, 3x all pro, etc.

 

[Ickey Shuffle]

AFC North ( My lifetime )

Bengals - Joe Burrow
Browns - Peyton Hillis
Ravens - Ray Lewis
Steelers - Troy Polamalu

 

[shopson67]

AFC North ( My lifetime )

Bengals - Joe Burrow
Browns - Peyton Hillis
Ravens - Ray Lewis
Steelers - Troy Polamalu

LOL at Peyton Hillis. Surely Garrett rates above him...

 

[Ickey Shuffle]

LOL at Peyton Hillis. Surely Garrett rates above him...

It was hard for the Browns .

If you wanna swap him out for Garrett, sure.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Bengals
Anthony Munoz
Ken Anderson
Boomer Esiason
Ken Riley (I pick him over OchoCinco)

Honorable mention: OchoCinco, Geno Atkins, Joe Burrow (I would be surprised if he wasn't very soon)

Browns
Jim Brown
Joe Thomas
Otto Graham
Ozzie Newsome

Honorable Mention: Paul Warfield, Myles Garrett (soon, very soon)

Ravens
Ray Lewis
Ed Reed
Jonathan Ogden
Terrell Suggs

Honorable mention: Lamar, Haloti Ngata

Steelers
Big Ben
Jack Lambert
Mean Joe Greene
Rod Woodson

Honorable Mention: Mel Blount, Terry Bradshaw, Troy Polamalu, Jack Ham, Alan Faneca

A top 4 for PIT is tough. You could make this a top 8. Bradshaw or Big Ben? Blount or Woodson?

 

[Shanemansj13]

It was hard for the Browns .

If you wanna swap him out for Garrett, sure.

Uhh Joe Thomas. Unless you are 10 years old