3-15-3 MLB Draft Semi-Final 2 : WLK vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

WLK

LINEUP
1. Brett Butler (L) - CF
2. Luis Castillo (B) - 2B
3. Ted Williams (L) - LF - HOF
4. Juan Gonzalez (R) - RF
5. Fred McGriff (L) - 1B
6. Al Rosen (R) - 3B
7. Mike LaValliere (L) - C - NAS
8. Ellis Burks (R) - DH
9. Omar Vizquel (B) - SS

PINCH HITTERS
Manny Mota (R) - PH
Shawn Green (L) - PH

ROTATION
1. Randy Johnson (L) - HOF
2. Pedro Martinez (R) - HOF
3. Frank Tanana (L)
4. Jose Rijo (R)
5. John Denny (R) - NAS

BULLPEN
Jeff Montgomery (R) - Closer
Dave Righetti (L) - RP Set Up Man
Rob Dibble (R) - RP Set Up Man
Tom Gordon (R) - Middle Reliever
Al Hbrowsky (L) - RP - NAS Lefty Specialist

VS

SHANE

LINEUP
1. Larry Walker (L) - RF
2. Jim Edmonds (L) - CF
3. Alex Rodriguez (R) - SS
4. Albert Pujols (R) - 1B - HOF
5. Mo Vaughn (L) - DH
6. Jeff Kent (R) - 2B
7. Jorge Posada (B) - C
8. John Valentin (R) - 3B - NAS
9. Johnny Damon (L) - LF

PINCH HITTERS
Hal Trosky (L) - NAS
Bobby Bonds (R)

ROTATION
1. Roger Clemens (R) - HOF
2. Ron Guidry (L)
3. Orel Hershiser (R)
4. Jimmy Key (L)
5. Charlie Liebrandt (L) - NAS

BULLPEN
Sparky Lyle (L)
Jeff Reardon (R)
Troy Percival (R)
Mike Marshall (R)
Gary Lavelle (L)

 

[Nosferatu]

WLK - 5
Shane - 2

Voted - Shane, Milk, WLK, Femur, Mebert, Ritz, UK

 

[Shanemansj13]

I think my lineup is better overall. His first 2 starters are great but my first 3 can matchup well enough IMO. I think my bullpen is one of the best in the draft. I got myself.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

this is close, so i might have to penalize Shane for Drafting Pujols over Jimmy Foxx... Kind of a HUGE blunder IMO...

I have WLK 3-2 for rotation
But prefer Shanes bullpen so their overall pitching staffs are near a wash IMO...

Offense is also very close... I don't think Pujols is a significant advantage on the other first baseman in this mock including crime dog... Yes he is better, but the difference is just not that significant IMO... and i think this ultimately hurts Shane....

I think i will go WLK, but this is as tight as it comes...

 

[wlk3]

I think my lineup is pretty good personally but let's not forget defense... My defense is much stronger all around... His 2B and LF are well below average and no others really stand out... I got me...

 

[femurov]

Close call, but I like Shane's lineup a little more. Everything else is close enough to make me give Shane the edge, but I agree Foxx would be better than Albert.

 

[Mebert]

Wlk

 

[Shanemansj13]

this is close, so i might have to penalize Shane for Drafting Pujols over Jimmy Foxx... Kind of a HUGE blunder IMO...

I have WLK 3-2 for rotation
But prefer Shanes bullpen so their overall pitching staffs are near a wash IMO...

Offense is also very close... I don't think Pujols is a significant advantage on the other first baseman in this mock including crime dog... Yes he is better, but the difference is just not that significant IMO... and i think this ultimately hurts Shane....

I think i will go WLK, but this is as tight as it comes...

I think you are overreacting on Pujols bc he an all-time great and better than All-Stars. I did think about Jimmie Foxx but for some reason I thought he was taken lol

 

[UK Cowboy]

WLK in a great series

 

[Ritzarmy]

I got WLK and god it's close. Very even on all spots.

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats WLK