1969 & 1996 Five HOFers QF1 : Mebert vs WLK

[Nosferatu]

MEEBS

LINEUP
1. Brett Butler (L) - CF - 96
2. Paul Molitor (R) - 2B - 96
3. Sammy Sosa (R) - RF - 96
4. Willie Stargell (L) - 1B - 69
5. Ivan Rodriguez (R) - C - 96
6. Reggie Smith (B) - DH - 69
7. Scott Rolen (R) - 3B - 96
8. Bert Campaneris (R) - SS - 69
9. Vince Coleman (B) - LF - 96

ROTATION
1. Tom Seaver (R) - 69
2. Greg Maddux (R) - 96
3. Bob Veale (L) - 69
4. Jim Kaat (L) - 69
5. Ray Culp (R) - 69

BULLPEN
Billy Wagner (L) - 96
Turk Farrell (R) - 69
Ron Perranoski (L) - 69
Greg Swindell (L) - 96
Stan Williams (R) - 96

VS

WLK

LINEUP
1. Lou Brock (L) - LF - 69
2. Vladimir Guerrero (R) - RF - 96
3. Ken Griffey Jr. (L) - CF - 96
4. Jose Canseco (R) - DH - 96
5. Fred McGriff (L) - 1B - 96
6. Johnny Bench (R) - C - 69
7. Bobby Bonilla (B) - 3B - 96
8. Julio Franco (R) - 2B - 96
9. Maury Wills (B) - SS - 69

ROTATION
1. Randy Johnson (L) - 96
2. Kevin Brown (R) - 96
3. David Wells (L) - 96
4. Phil Niekro (R) - 69
5. Jim Maloney (R) - 69

BULLPEN
Trevor Hoffman (R) - 96
John Hiller (L) - 69
Moe Drawbosky (R) - 69
Dick Radatz (R) - 69
Ted Abernathy (R) - 69

 

[Nosferatu]

Meebs - 2
WLK - 6

VOTED - Stoke, Femur, UK, Ritz, Nos, WLK, Meebs, Shane

 

[femurov]

WLK

 

[Ritzarmy]

WLK.

(Didn't think we could post platoon like Meebs did. I was told it had to be next to the player in lineup. This is not why I voted for WLK but just basically asking)

 

[blstoker]

Wlk

 

[UK Cowboy]

WLK

 

[Nosferatu]

WLK.

(Didn't think we could post platoon like Meebs did. I was told it had to be next to the player in lineup. This is not why I voted for WLK but just basically asking)

What? You are crazy!

 

[Nosferatu]

I gotta lean Meebs here, slight edge to WLK in lineup slight edge to Meebs in rotation but if it comes to a game 7 i'll take Maddux all day over Kevin Brown.

 

[Ritzarmy]

What? You are crazy!

I posted it like that and you yelled at me saying no post it like Shane's where he had players next to player.

You don't just list platoon like that put them next to who they will platoon with and show their position.

 

[Nosferatu]

I posted it like that and you yelled at me saying no post it like Shane's where he had players next to player.

Yes and? That's how Meebs has it too...

 

[Pack 500]

WLK

 

[Nosferatu]

Why didn't @Shanemansj13 vote in this one?

 

[Mebert]

Me

 

[Shanemansj13]

Gotta go WLK by a slight edge

 

[Nosferatu]

Congrats WLK

 

[MilkSpiller22]

i don't think i have ever called for a tie... but i am here... i don't want to cast a vote, because i think this would be a stalemate...

but since there is no ties in baseball i will give it to the team with the better 5th starter and that is WLK...

 

[wlk3]