"12 Best college football players who didn't win the Heisman." SN

[Pariah]

If you're into CFB history, Tommy McDonald is a good one.

 

[TheDayMan]

Reggie Bush


/thread

I see what you did there.

 

[HuskerOC]

Reggie Bush


/thread

Nope.

Can't end a thread on a pussy.

Reggie Bush is a pussy.

 

[Great Dayne]

 

[Great Dayne]

Melvin Gordon is easily #1 on this list with over 2500 rushing yards, 32 TD's and 2800 yards from scrimmage. The dude averaged about 8 YPC for his fucking career best of all time for P5 players. Dude is the gold standard for RB's in college.

 

[Great Dayne]

Nope.

Can't end a thread on a pussy.

Reggie Bush is a pussy.

Melvin Gordon ended the thread by Grabbing them by the pussy.

 

[Lions=TeHsUcKs]

Anthony Carter
Randy Moss
Eric Dickerson
Marshall Faulk
John Elway
Dick Butkus
Braylon Edwards

 

[B_dub]

Anthony Carter

What the fuck is it with Michigan fans and reading pertaining to this thread?

 

[Lions=TeHsUcKs]

What the fuck is it with Michigan fans and reading pertaining to this thread?

He was one of Michigan's greatests! I mean I can't be a full on homer and name guys like Jake Long and Steve Hutchinson like someone named with Orlando Pace. As great of a Tackle he was.

 

[B_dub]

He was one of Michigan's greatests! I mean I can't be a full on homer and name guys like Jake Long and Steve Hutchinson like someone named with Orlando Pace. As great of a Tackle he was.

Hes on the list, or are you just saying he's #1 in your rankings?

 

[Lions=TeHsUcKs]

Hes on the list, or are you just saying he's #1?

He's on a list of many. He didn't have the NFL success of some of the great Michigan players like Hutchinson or Ty Law, but he was super productive in college. No. 1 on my list would probably be Jim Brown. I mean how the fuck did he not win a Heisman? He was straight up a 2000s athlete in the 50s.

 

[B_dub]

He's on a list of many. He didn't have the NFL success of some of the great Michigan players like Hutchinson or Ty Law, but he was super productive in college. No. 1 on my list would probably be Jim Brown. I mean how the fuck did he not win a Heisman? He was straight up a 2000s athlete in the 50s.

No doubt. Dude was a absolute freak.

 

[Lions=TeHsUcKs]

No doubt. Dude was a absolute freak.

Greatest Lacrosse player as well.

 

[theSabanator20]

Darren McFadden
Andrew Luck
Kellen Moore
Derrick Thomas
Calvin Johnson
Kyle Rudolph
Barrett Jones
Case Keenum

Troy Smith winning the Heisman still eludes me.

Hell....

Montee Ball
Andy Dalton
LaMichael James
Aaron Murray
Eric Berry
Michael Crabtree
Colt McCoy


This list really could go on

 

[thunderc]

AP is too low.

Yes WAAAAY too low. Generational back.

 

[Smart]

Yes WAAAAY too low. Generational back.

Adrian Peterson: 748 carries, 4041 Yards, 5.4 YPC, 41 TDs
Melvin Gordon: 631 carries, 4,915 yards, 7.8 YPC, 45 TDs

Yep, that Adrian Peterson sure is underrated.

 

[Chewbaccer]

Darren McFadden
Andrew Luck
Kellen Moore
Derrick Thomas
Calvin Johnson
Kyle Rudolph
Barrett Jones
Case Keenum

Troy Smith winning the Heisman still eludes me.

Hell....

Montee Ball
Andy Dalton
LaMichael James
Aaron Murray
Eric Berry
Michael Crabtree
Colt McCoy


This list really could go on

Aaron Murray never came close to being Heisman worthy. Todd Gurley maybe.

 

[Smart]

Melvin Gordon is easily #1 on this list with over 2500 rushing yards, 32 TD's and 2800 yards from scrimmage. The dude averaged about 8 YPC for his fucking career best of all time for P5 players. Dude is the gold standard for RB's in college.

It blows my mind that it took until the Wisconsin homer on Page 3 to mention him. With the possible exception on Young, nobody on this thread had a season which can even argue was close to his 2014.

 

[Across The Field]

Zeke Elliott belongs on this list, as well.

 

[ckhokie]

Michael Vick should be #1 on this list. Pretty ridiculous he isn't even ranked, unless this is just another hack writer still butthurt about the dog thing.