You Get Two Teams MLB Draft S16 2 : 500 1 vs Shane 1

[Nosferatu]

500

LINEUP
1. Nap Lajoie (R) - 2B
2. Bobby Abreu (L) - RF
3. Dick Allen (R) - 3B
4. Hank Greenberg (R) - 1B
5. Eddie Murray (B) - DH
6. Ryan Braun (R) - LF
7. Cal Ripken (R) - SS
8. Jim Edmonds (L) - CF
9. Joe Torre (R) - C

ROTATION
1. Walter Johnson (R)
2. Grover Cleveland Alexander (R)
3. Gaylord Perry (R)
4. David Cone (R)
5. Cliff Lee (L)

BULLPEN
Jonathan Papelbon (R)
David Robertson (R)
Matt Thornton (L)
Mark Eichhorn (R)
Larry Anderson (R)

VS

SHANE

LINEUP
1. Eddie Collins (L) - 2B
2. Shoeless Joe Jackson (L) - LF
3. Mike Schmidt (R) - 3B
4. Todd Helton (L) - 1B
5. Harry Heilmann (R) - RF
6. Andre Dawson (R) - CF
7. Dan Brouthers (L) - DH
8. Gabby Hartnett (R) - C
9. Bill Dahlen (R) - SS

ROTATION
1. Sandy Koufax (L)
2. Fergie Jenkins (R)
3. Kid Nichols (R)
4. Don Sutton (R)
5. Mike Cuellar (L)

BULLPEN
Zach Britton (L)
Jeff Montgomery (R)
Greg Holland (R)
Don Mossi (L)
Don McMahon (R)

 

[Nosferatu]

500 1 - 6
SHANE 1 - 2

VOTED - Shane, 500, Femu, WLK, Meebs, Nos, UK, Devil

Race to 5

 

[Shanemansj13]

He 1-2 is deadly but I also think my 1-4 rotation is pretty damn good. I also like my lineup quite a bit more.

I got me

 

[Pack 500]

Totally disagree on the lineup. Your top 3 is better but after that I have the edge in every spot IMO. I vote me.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Totally disagree on the lineup. Your top 3 is better but after that I have the edge in every spot IMO. I vote me.

My top 3 is much better. You have Greenberg as the advantage, from there on out my lineup has quite an advantage imo.

Murray-Braun-Ripken-Edmonds-Torrre
Heilmann-Dawson-Brouthers-Hartnett-Dahlen

I don’t see that being close considering you have two of the most overrated players ever and I might have two underrated guys in Heilmann and Brouthers. I would be interested to see the numbers but I am too lazy to post and I don’t care enough about winning this haha. I did make this post so I care a little though

 

[femurov]

500

 

[wlk3]

500

 

[Mebert]

Shane

 

[Nosferatu]

I got 500 in this one although

Dawson > Braun

 

[TheRobotDevil]

500

 

[UK Cowboy]

500

 

[Pack 500]

My top 3 is much better. You have Greenberg as the advantage, from there on out my lineup has quite an advantage imo.

Murray-Braun-Ripken-Edmonds-Torrre
Heilmann-Dawson-Brouthers-Hartnett-Dahlen

I don’t see that being close considering you have two of the most overrated players ever and I might have two underrated guys in Heilmann and Brouthers. I would be interested to see the numbers but I am too lazy to post and I don’t care enough about winning this haha. I did make this post so I care a little though

A shortstop with great defense, two MVPs and around 450 homers drafted in what was essentially the 18th round and hitting seventh can’t possibly be overrated

 

[Pack 500]

I got 500 in this one although

Dawson > Braun

Braun .302/.364/540
Dawson .279/.323/.482

Braun has 6 seasons of over 30 homers in 11 years while Dawson has 3 in 21 years. Braun six seasons of 20 or more doubles. Dawson four. Braun walks a ton more obviously. Braun also has good speed to match Dawson as well. Don't see how this close unless you want to use the steroid card.

 

[Nosferatu]

Braun .302/.364/540
Dawson .279/.323/.482

Braun has 6 seasons of over 30 homers in 11 years while Dawson has 3 in 21 years. Braun six seasons of 20 or more doubles. Dawson four. Braun walks a ton more obviously. Braun also has good speed to match Dawson as well. Don't see how this close unless you want to use the steroid card.

So Braun hits more home runs in a time when everyone is hitting more home runs. I won't play the steroid card but look what hes done since he was busted and he hasn't had the end of the career fall to hurt his overall numbers yet.

 

[Pack 500]

So Braun hits more home runs in a time when everyone is hitting more home runs. I won't play the steroid card but look what hes done since he was busted and he hasn't had the end of the career fall to hurt his overall numbers yet.

He does a lot more than hit more homers. Higher average, on base by a lot and more doubles. I'll always take peak over compilers prolonging their careers. Braun's prime years are way better. Dawson isn't a HOFer in my world.

 

[Nosferatu]

He does a lot more than hit more homers. Higher average, on base by a lot and more doubles. I'll always take peak over compilers prolonging their careers. Braun's prime years are way better. Dawson isn't a HOFer in my world.

Yeah, well, you drink pee!

 

[Pack 500]

Yeah, well, you drink pee!