Keeper thoughts

[thedddd]

This is a 20 team league with 24 man rosters/19 starting with the standard positions with an extra IF and a 4th OF and a UTIL and 8 pitchers.

I keep 5 players each year and the first 4 are locks.
Now I need to decide on my fifth keeper:

So pick one out of this group:

Ian Desmond
Matt Carpenter
Matt Olson
Adam Eaton

Really no real preference from my side just curious on others thoughts.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

This is a 20 team league with 24 man rosters/19 starting with the standard positions with an extra IF and a 4th OF and a UTIL and 8 pitchers.

I keep 5 players each year and the first 4 are locks.
Now I need to decide on my fifth keeper:

So pick one out of this group:

Ian Desmond
Matt Carpenter
Matt Olson
Adam Eaton

Really no real preference from my side just curious on others thoughts.

Easily Desmond. But, Olson is interesting. The other 2 are not even close

 

[thedddd]

^Yeah Olson is interesting but my concern with him was it a fluke or will he be Joey Gallo?
Then Desmond is health but not as bad as with Carpenter and Eaton.
Also I forgot to mention the 5x5 scoring for hitters is OBP and not AVG.

To be honest it wouldn't be a hard decision if I had a better 5th keeper!

Thanks!

 

[MilkSpiller22]

^Yeah Olson is interesting but my concern with him was it a fluke or will he be Joey Gallo?
Then Desmond is health but not as bad as with Carpenter and Eaton.
Also I forgot to mention the 5x5 scoring for hitters is OBP and not AVG.

To be honest it wouldn't be a hard decision if I had a better 5th keeper!

Thanks!

desmond is 1B/OF elligible and plays for colorado... even if he gets hurt and plays 120 its still 120 for colorado... and you have the flexibility...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Olson for me.
Desmond isn't promised anything with the amount of bats available in Colorado.