• Have something to say? Register Now! and be posting in minutes!

Dynasty Would You Rather

ehb5

HTTR
8,718
1,388
173
Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Location
State College, PA
Hoopla Cash
$ 11,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Im going to assume PPR for these but if you play standard and are basing your picks off that just state so I guess

So in dynasty...would you rather have ...

Julio Jones or 1.02

Zeke or 1.01

OBJ or 1.01

Fournette or Kareem Hunt

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson

Gronk or Ertz

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill

AROB or Davante Adams

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry

Ok thats probably enough...have at it!
 

ehb5

HTTR
8,718
1,388
173
Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Location
State College, PA
Hoopla Cash
$ 11,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Ill go with...

Julio Jones or 1.02...personally this one isnt close for me but Im betting Ill get some push back on this

Zeke or 1.01...zeke has character concerns but as much as I love saquon, this comes down to proven vs unproven

OBJ or 1.01...the answer is always OBJ

Fournette or Kareem Hunt...I just think Hunt is better and may be a little more built to last. Kamara (and maybe Cook) also fit into this discussion. Could make any order between them probably

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon...super close. I think Howard is more likely to lose his job though

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry...both high upside guys, but Mixons a less proven but better prospect and has less competition for touches

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy...this is a fun one. How much do we buy into the Mckinnon hype. Im in over a 29 year old RB even if hes a stud

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson...both young star QBs coming off ACLs. Wentz a larger sample of being good (even if he is overrated :D)

Gronk or Ertz... gotta go with the GOAT. the risk is worth the reward IMO

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen...damn close. Thomas is SLIGHTLY (less than a year) younger so Ill go him

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill - I would have gone Hill before Sammy signed. Both young speed guys

AROB or Davante Adams - AROB by a decent amount IMO but Adams does have Rodgers

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton...Cooper is obviously younger but what the hell happened last year?

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster...this is the hardest one for me. Love Davis' potential and Juju has no path to being the #1 option but at least hes proven hes a legit NFL receiver

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry...I think I would have gone Landry if he were still in Miami
 

SmokingMonkey

MLS....come to STL!!!
12,349
7,007
533
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Location
STL
Hoopla Cash
$ 7,521.41
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio, Zeke, OBJ, give me the known stud over the 'what could be'
Fournette, Gordon, Henry, McKinnon, Wentz, Ertz, Thomas, Cooks, Adams, Hilton, Juju, Thielen - just feel like the other sides of these are old or on worse teams
 

broncosmitty

Banned in Europe
89,666
23,583
1,033
Joined
Apr 19, 2013
Location
Almost Paradise
Hoopla Cash
$ 16,206.54
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02. Jones

Zeke or 1.01. 1.01


OBJ or 1.01. OBJ

Fournette or Kareem Hunt. Hunt

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon. Howard

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry. Ugh. Henry?

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy. McKinnon

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson. Wentz

Gronk or Ertz. Ertz

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen. Thomas

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill. Cooks

AROB or Davante Adams. Adams. But I don't like his hands. Only because of ARodg

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton. Hilton

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster. Idk. Davis hands aren't that great. Trust me. And I'm no fan of Marriota.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry. Landry
 

averagejoe

You fell victim to one of the classic blunders.
13,245
7,166
533
Joined
Apr 19, 2013
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,500.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
So in dynasty...would you rather have ...

Julio Jones or 1.02 - Would much rather have the 2nd pick.

Zeke or 1.01 - Right now, Zeke is atop my board as the #1 pick anyway.

OBJ or 1.01 - Not touching OBJ.

Fournette or Kareem Hunt - Fournette's ypc has me concerned. Gimme Hunt.

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon - better offense.
I think Howard is more likely to lose his job though
No way Howard loses his job. But he may not see much on passing downs. Nagy has said he wants to use Cohen all over the field. But Cohen is NOT a between-the-tackles runner.​

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry - Not sold on Henry. And apparently neither is TEN since they signed Dion Lewis.

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson - I personally don't like rookies who get hurt their first year. Just never a good sign IMO.

Gronk or Ertz - **gag** Gronk, even tho he misses 80% of his games. Ertz at least shows up for 94%.

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen - was an Allen owner and lost patience with him, so I'm bias.

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill - Gonna go Hill. Cooks is the 3rd option on a good offense (behind Gronk & Edelman) while Hill is 2nd behind the often concussed Kelce.

AROB or Davante Adams - I'm hoping ARob pans out as a fan. But Adams is the new #1 in GB and his QB is already elite.

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton - this one is close. If Luck is 100% then it's Hilton by a mile. I don't trust Gruden.

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster - JuJu is a nice compliment. Davis is still unproven in my book. But I will say that if I had the WR depth, I'd take a shot on Davis since he has the chance to be the #1.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry - this is a nice problem to have. Gonna go with Thielen only because of the supporting cast in Minny. CLE still has to break it's curse - not just on paper.
 
Last edited:

averagejoe

You fell victim to one of the classic blunders.
13,245
7,166
533
Joined
Apr 19, 2013
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,500.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
ulio Jones or 1.02 - Would much rather have the 2nd pick.

Zeke or 1.01 - Right now, Zeke is atop my board as the #1 pick anyway.

OBJ or 1.01 - Not touching OBJ.
Sorry. I misunderstood. Treated this like a redraft.
Gimme the established vets.
 

obxyankeefan

Well-Known Member
24,362
8,669
533
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Location
Not where I want to be
Hoopla Cash
$ 63,137.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02. Jones

Zeke or 1.01. 1.01


OBJ or 1.01. OBJ

Fournette or Kareem Hunt. Fournette

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon. Howard

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry. Ugh. Henry?

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy. McKinnon

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson. Wentz

Gronk or Ertz. Ertz

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen. Thomas

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill. Cooks

AROB or Davante Adams. ARob

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton. Hilton

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster. JJSS

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry. Thielen
 

Stomp

Lions Homer
6,090
1,827
173
Joined
Jul 20, 2013
Location
Alaska
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02 Love Chubb and Guice, for redraft Julio is nice, but longterm a big bodied guy with a bum foot = short career

Zeke or 1.01 Zeke is going to get himself kicked out of the league

OBJ or 1.01 OBJ is the 3rd most valuable dynasty asset this season imo

Fournette or Kareem Hunt I like Hunt better, but Fournette has the value

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon this one isn't close

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry both likely in a split backfield Bernard is a better player than Mixon if he can stay on the field

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy WAT

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson Both played great last year

Gronk or Ertz Gronk isn't retiring

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill I do like cooks this season, But Hill is an awesome weapon and i trust Andy more than BB

AROB or Davante Adams

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry
 
Last edited:

MilkSpiller22

Gorilla
33,626
6,376
533
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Hoopla Cash
$ 89,217.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02- Depends on the year, but i might go with the mystery pick... Jones is so frustrating because he just doesn't get the TDs... and now he is getting OLD- BUT IN A PPR LEAGUE WHERE YOU CAN START MORE THAN 3 WRs THEN JONES IS THE CLEAR KEEP>>.

Zeke or 1.01- Zeke is everything you would want from 1.01, why not keep it safe

OBJ or 1.01- Depends on the year, but i guess in a PPR league OBJ is the SAFER keep...

Fournette or Kareem Hunt- Fournette has the better role IMO... HE IS THE OFFENSE, we dont know this new KC offense yet

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon- Howard smells bad,

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry- TIE

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy- dont care if it is a dynasty or not, you dont pick a bench player that needs to prove himself over a top 10 RB... you can trade McCoy during the season and get MUCH more than mcKinnon

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson- this might as well be a tie, but i am basing this on the teams defense... Houston SUCKED last year...

Gronk or Ertz- Gronk is game changing

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen- less injury prone

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill- i hate patriots skill players besides Gronk, you never know the game plan... at least Hill is the number one receiver..

AROB or Davante Adams- elite talent gets new team

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton- WHO CARES!!! they are both players you SETTLE on

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster- the talent and more direct path to be the WR1

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry- he is the new Eric Decker, Just very consistent...

Ok thats probably enough...have at it!
 

Bandit

RIP to the real Bandit
6,138
4,814
293
Joined
Jul 13, 2013
Location
Titusville, FL
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
This is really difficult without knowing what the rest of the roster might be, but I'll give it a shot:

Julio Jones or 1.02 - Give me the 1.02 and I would trade it to somebody that needs running backs for a better wide receiver than Julio

Zeke or 1.01 - And this one isn't even remotely close

OBJ or 1.01 - I'd rather have Barkley with the drama of OBJ

Fournette or Kareem Hunt - Hunt's just too much better in the passing game

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon - The Chargers just trust Gordon a lot more

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry - This one's tough, but I'll take the guy that averages more than 3.5ypc

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy - This one is close also, but I'll give the advantage to Mckinnon because I think Mccoy only has two more years left in him.

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson - Everybody knows how much I love Watson

Gronk or Ertz - I still wouldn't take any other tight end over Gronk.

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen - I think Keenan Allen is just a better receiver and Brees is 40 so Michael Thomas is going to have a mystery quarterback sooner than Allen

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill - Cooks just has a way of disappearing in way too many games

AROB or Davante Adams - Well let's think, Mitch Trubisky or Aaron Rodgers?

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton - AMARI COOPER CAN'T CATCH!!

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster - I honestly could see either one of them but Davis's quarterback hasn't talked about retiring in the near future.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry - Thielen has the better quarterback for now, but Landry is a better football player and that always wins out in the long run

Ok thats probably enough...have at it!
 

Stomp

Lions Homer
6,090
1,827
173
Joined
Jul 20, 2013
Location
Alaska
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Jerrick Mckinnon was worse than Asiata when AD went down in 16 and the 49ers line isn't close to what the Vikings line was last year. Mckinnon was left wide open a ton last year he took what the defense gave him and no more.
 

broncosmitty

Banned in Europe
89,666
23,583
1,033
Joined
Apr 19, 2013
Location
Almost Paradise
Hoopla Cash
$ 16,206.54
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02 Love Chubb and Guice, for redraft Julio is nice, but longterm a big bodied guy with a bum foot = short career

Zeke or 1.01 Zeke is going to get himself kicked out of the league

OBJ or 1.01 OBJ is the 3rd most valuable dynasty asset this season imo

Fournette or Kareem Hunt I like Hunt better, but Fournette has the value

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon this one isn't close

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry both likely in a split backfield Bernard is a better player than Mixon if he can stay on the field

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy WAT

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson Both played great last year

Gronk or Ertz Gronk isn't retiring

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill I do like cooks this season, But Hill is an awesome weapon and i trust Andy more than BB

AROB or Davante Adams

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry
Who all do you have ahead of OBJ?

Gurley and DJ?
 

Trudem

He's no good to me dead!
11,981
2,646
293
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Location
Jax, FL
Hoopla Cash
$ 350.34
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02 – Proven commodity even though he needs to score more TDs

Zeke or 1.01 – One of the few dynasty blue chips

OBJ or 1.01 – when on the field he might be the most productive player at his position

Fournette or Kareem Hunt – Offense is built around him and they added to the OL

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon – YPC might not be great but this guy just scores TDs

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry – TN doesn’t trust Henry…why should I?

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy – He has been doing it for too long. I have doubted him too long

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson – much better weapons

Gronk or Ertz – I just cant trust Gronk to stay on the field

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen – Best WR on an elite offense and thus far has stayed healthy

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill – gives you points in the passing, run and ST game. More opportunities to score

AROB or Davante Adams – Give me the guy that AR is slinging to with 22 TDs the last two years

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton – Doesn’t have questionable hands and has put up points with trash at QB

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster – I don’t trust Mariotta to throw enough

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry – Intermediate route vacuum and I expect Cleveland to get better fast.


I am happy to see several of my guys on here!
 

DALLAScornhusker

Well-Known Member
1,325
309
83
Joined
Jul 17, 2013
Location
Motor Boating
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Im going to assume PPR for these but if you play standard and are basing your picks off that just state so I guess

So in dynasty...would you rather have ...

Julio Jones or 1.02

Zeke or 1.01

OBJ or 1.01

Fournette or Kareem Hunt

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy (Neither are long-term answers)

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson

Gronk or Ertz

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill

AROB or Davante Adams (Have both, like Adams better)

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton (Not fond of either)

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster PUSH

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry

Ok thats probably enough...have at it!
 

TREFF

Fantasy Football Guru--??
32,711
12,088
1,033
Joined
Apr 17, 2013
Location
Colorado-behind enemy lines
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02 - honestly would take either, the deciding factor being what I need on my roster. I think Julio, as great as he is, is gonna start a sharp decline very soon. All those nagging injuries that keep him out for a series here and there, or a quarter, or a half, are going to start equating games missed. And he hasn't exactly been elite lately anyways.

Zeke or 1.01 Zeke, without question. Maybe Barkley ends up better, not taking that chance knowing full well what Zeke can do

OBJ or 1.01 - gladly take Barkley. Anyone stupid enough to allow video of weed, a hooker, and cocaine all in one clip, is a ticking time bomb waiting for a lifetime ban. Someone else can have his production until then

Fournette or Kareem Hunt - Hunt, KC's offense seems much more stable. If nothing else..Andy Died, nuff said

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon - Howard. Gordon gets outplayed by no names too often to be a long term asset

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry - Henry, more faith in the Titans than the Bengals figuring it out

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy - McCoy, McKinnon wasn't as great as he seemed. And Shanny loves splitting touches. I have doubts he can do what would need to be done to justify that valuation with a D. Freeman- esque load

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson - Wentz. I'll always choose the pocket passer over the runner who relies on big plays for their points

Gronk or Ertz - Ertz. Longevity and similar enough production for short term

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen - Thomas. Both Bree's and Rivers are short timers at this point, but the Saints seem like they'd be more apt to maintain an aerial attack after their HOF QB is gone.

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill -Hill, still say Cooks is the most operated WR playing today, even matching him with Brady didn't move him into elite status. Hill has value outside of deep routes

AROB or Davante Adams -Adams without question. No Jordy, Rodgers new unquestioned #1, vs Trubisky's #1..why would there be a doubt?

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton -Cooper, but, only because I don't want to bank on Luck.

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster- Davis. Big Ben wishy washy, L. Bell probably gone soon, the #2 in that offense doesn't gave longterm appeal.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry - Thielen, Landry is perfectly fine, but, no thanks
 

HaroldSeattle

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
56,146
21,832
1,033
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Location
Twin Peaks
Hoopla Cash
$ 45.14
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Julio Jones or 1.02 Lots depends on my roster, but if I'm a Jones owner I'm looking to trade him while his value is still good. Give me 1.02

Zeke or 1.01 Zeke

OBJ or 1.01 1.01 OBJ has just to many question marks. He's coming off a injury, looks like he may get traded and if he isn't he's playing with ancient Eli and a crappy OL? Besides OBJ is just to much of a head case for dynasty.

Fournette or Kareem Hunt PPR you would think Hunt right? However his usage has been a head scratcher, for a long spell the Chiefs quit using him much. Fournette is the offense centerpiece and that's not going to change. Fournette for me.

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon This is a tough one, think I'll go Gordan, but not confidently.

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry Another tough one. Henry has a very good OL, he should do well, Mixon doesn't. However this is dynasty and Mixon is easily the more talented RB in my mind. The quality difference in the OL will change over their career. Give me the more talented RB. I'll go Mixon.

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy Are you kidding me? McCoy. Mckinnon is a JAG

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson Wentz

Gronk or Ertz This is dynasty guys, Ertz is good now he'll be good tomorrow. Ertz

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen Thomas just because I don't trust Allen to stay healthy.

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill Hill Never been a big fan of Cooks

AROB or Davante Adams Another are you fu***ing kidding me? Adams

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton Hilton, but only because Cooper been disappointing FF owners his whole career

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster Corey Davis go with the better talent.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry Thielen he"s on the rise and Landry isn't





 

SmokingMonkey

MLS....come to STL!!!
12,349
7,007
533
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Location
STL
Hoopla Cash
$ 7,521.41
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy Are you kidding me? McCoy. Mckinnon is a JAG


AROB or Davante Adams Another are you fu***ing kidding me? Adams

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton Hilton, but only because Cooper been disappointing FF owners his whole career


:pound:

love your comments
 

ehb5

HTTR
8,718
1,388
173
Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Location
State College, PA
Hoopla Cash
$ 11,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
So in dynasty...would you rather have ...

Julio Jones or 1.02 - Would much rather have the 2nd pick.

Zeke or 1.01 - Right now, Zeke is atop my board as the #1 pick anyway.

OBJ or 1.01 - Not touching OBJ.

Fournette or Kareem Hunt - Fournette's ypc has me concerned. Gimme Hunt.

Jordan Howard or Melvin Gordon - better offense.

No way Howard loses his job. But he may not see much on passing downs. Nagy has said he wants to use Cohen all over the field. But Cohen is NOT a between-the-tackles runner.​

Joe Mixon or Derrick Henry - Not sold on Henry. And apparently neither is TEN since they signed Dion Lewis.

Jerrick Mckinnon or Lesean McCoy

Carson Wentz or Deshaun Watson - I personally don't like rookies who get hurt their first year. Just never a good sign IMO.

Gronk or Ertz - **gag** Gronk, even tho he misses 80% of his games. Ertz at least shows up for 94%.

Michael Thomas or Keenan Allen - was an Allen owner and lost patience with him, so I'm bias.

Brandin Cooks or Tyreek Hill - Gonna go Hill. Cooks is the 3rd option on a good offense (behind Gronk & Edelman) while Hill is 2nd behind the often concussed Kelce.

AROB or Davante Adams - I'm hoping ARob pans out as a fan. But Adams is the new #1 in GB and his QB is already elite.

Amari Cooper or TY Hilton - this one is close. If Luck is 100% then it's Hilton by a mile. I don't trust Gruden.

Corey Davis or Juju Smith-Schuster - JuJu is a nice compliment. Davis is still unproven in my book. But I will say that if I had the WR depth, I'd take a shot on Davis since he has the chance to be the #1.

Adam Thielen or Jarvis Landry - this is a nice problem to have. Gonna go with Thielen only because of the supporting cast in Minny. CLE still has to break it's curse - not just on paper.

Yea I definitely dont think Howard will lose his job this year or next but as you said he loses work on passing downs. Between that and the fact hes just a former 5th round pick it makes it easy to move in a new direction. Not immediately, but when it becomes convenient for Chicago. Reminds me of Alfred Morris (a 6th round non pass catching back).

Does it make a difference to have torn your acl in year 1 vs year 2? I do agree Id rather have Wentz though.

Yea I dont trust Gruden either lol. Good point.
 
Top